Marine Insurance

Boat Insurance Myths That Can Sink You (Literally and Financially)

Let's dive into some persistent myths that can drain your bank account.
Sun Coast Team
May 19, 2025

You've got the life jackets stowed, the safety kit organized, and the GPS calibrated to perfection. Your checklist for National Safe Boating Week seems complete. But wait—what about your insurance? That critical document might be the only thing keeping you financially afloat if things go sideways on the water.

National Safe Boating Week isn't just about avoiding physical hazards—it's about navigating financial ones too. Let's dive into some persistent myths that could leave you stranded, uninsured, or unnecessarily draining your bank account faster than a boat with a bilge pump failure.

The Myths Many Boaters Believe

Myth #1: "My Homeowners Policy Has My Boat Covered"

Only partly—and only sometimes.

Most homeowners policies have strict limitations when it comes to your aquatic adventures. They typically only cover small boats (think under 16 feet) with minimal horsepower. Got anything bigger or more powerful? You're probably sailing in uninsured waters.

Even more concerning, home insurance rarely includes liability coverage for accidents that happen while you're actually on the water. That peaceful day of fishing could turn into a financial nightmare if someone gets injured.

Your home policy might help if your small boat is stolen from your driveway. But once you hit the water? You're largely on your own.

Myth #2: "I Don't Need Insurance for a Small or Older Boat"

Accidents don't check your boat's age or size before happening.

That 15-year-old fishing boat might not be worth what it once was, but repairing or replacing it after an accident can still cost thousands. Not to mention, the age of your vessel has absolutely zero impact on your liability if you cause injury to others.

Think about it: if your older boat causes $100,000 in medical bills to another boater, you're responsible regardless of whether your boat is worth $5,000 or $50,000. The math doesn't add up in your favor.

Coverage matters no matter what you float. Period.

Myth #3: "I'm Covered No Matter Who's Driving My Boat"

Surprise! Many policies have strict rules about who can operate your vessel.

Some insurance policies only cover named operators—people specifically listed on your policy. Hand the wheel to your buddy for a quick spin without checking your policy first? You might have just voided your coverage entirely.

This isn't just fine print—it's a potential economic disaster waiting to happen. Always check your policy's permitted operator clause before letting someone else take control.

Myth #4: "If I'm Not Using My Boat, I Don't Need Insurance"

Off-season doesn't mean off-risk.

Many insurance claims happen when boats are sitting in storage. Fire, theft, vandalism, storm damage—these threats don't take winter vacations. In fact, some of the most catastrophic losses happen while boats are supposedly "safe" in storage.

Canceling during the off-season might save a few dollars in premiums but could cost you the entire value of your boat if disaster strikes while it's tucked away.

The savings rarely justify the risk.

Myth #5: "All Boat Insurance Policies Are Created Equal"

Every boat is unique. Just like their captains.

A fishing boat cruising calm inland lakes faces entirely different risks than an offshore vessel battling coastal currents. Your coverage requirements shift dramatically based on your boat's purpose, cruising territory, and frequency of use.

Without tailored protection, you're either overpaying for irrelevant coverage—or dangerously underprotected against the specific hazards you're most likely to encounter.

The Reality of Responsible Boat Ownership

Smart boaters know that proper insurance isn't just a regulatory checkbox—it's a critical component of responsible ownership. Just as you wouldn't skimp on life jackets or navigation equipment, you shouldn't cut corners on financial protection.

The statistics don't lie: according to the U.S. Coast Guard, there are thousands of boating accidents annually resulting in hundreds of millions in property damage. Without proper coverage, those repair costs come directly from your pocket.

Beyond the Basics: What Your Policy Should Include

A truly comprehensive boat insurance policy should include:

  • Hull coverage for physical damage to your vessel
  • Liability protection for injuries or damage you cause to others
  • Medical payments for injuries to you and your passengers
  • Uninsured boater coverage for accidents with uninsured vessels
  • Towing and assistance coverage for when you're stranded
  • Fuel spill liability for environmental protection
  • Personal effects coverage for equipment and belongings

Bonus Tip: Know Before You Float

The absolute worst time to review your coverage is after you need it. By then, it's too late.

At Sun Coast General, we specialize in helping boaters understand exactly what's included in their policies, what exclusions might leave them vulnerable, and how to fill those gaps without overpaying. Our team of marine insurance experts can review your current coverage to identify potential issues before they become costly problems.

Don't want to spend hours deciphering insurance jargon? We get it. Schedule a quick consultation with one of our specialists who can translate the complex language into plain English and help you make informed decisions.

Final Thoughts: Stay Afloat, Stay Protected

National Safe Boating Week is the perfect time to ensure you're not just physically safe on the water, but financially protected as well. The right insurance policy delivers something invaluable: peace of mind while you enjoy your time on the water.

Remember that boat insurance isn't just about protecting your vessel—it's about protecting your financial future, your passengers, and other boaters who share the waterways with you.

Don't let insurance myths sink your boating season or your bank account. Get the facts, secure proper coverage, and then you can truly relax and enjoy those sunny days on the water knowing you're protected from bow to stern.

Contact our marine specialists today to ensure you're fully covered before your next voyage. After all, the only surprises you want on your boat should involve the size of the fish you catch—not the size of an unexpected bill after an accident.

Ready to Hit the Water?
See how much you could save on boat insurance today.
Quote my Boat
Marine Insurance
Written by
Sun Coast Team
May 19, 2025
Co-written by multiple experts within the Sun Coast editorial team.
Share this article
Support

Got questions about Boat Insurance?

We have answers for you on all things insurance.
Can I cancel my boat insurance during the off-season?
You may be able to, but it may leave your boat unprotected against fire, theft, vandalism, or weather-related damage while in storage. Maintaining year-round coverage helps protect your investment even when your boat isn’t in use
Are all boat insurance policies the same?
No—coverage varies based on vessel type, location, usage, and insurer. A policy that’s ideal for inland lake fishing might not suit offshore boating. Always tailor your coverage to your boating lifestyle.
What kinds of risks does boat insurance typically cover?
Many policies can include physical damage (hull coverage), liability, medical payments, towing and assistance, fuel spill liability, and more—but specific features vary by provider. Be sure to review your policy carefully.
Does boat insurance cover personal items like fishing gear or electronics?
Some policies offer optional personal effects coverage, but it’s not always standard. Ask your agent whether this protection is available and what limits apply.
Will insurance help if my boat breaks down on the water?
Many boat insurance policies offer optional towing and assistance coverage, which can help with breakdowns, fuel delivery, or emergency transport. Coverage details and limits vary.
Our blog

Want to learn more about insurance?

The Sun Coast Blog is your go-to guide for all insurance knowledge.

Get a quote with Sun Coast and see how much you can save on Insurance

Comparing our carrier’s rates and coverage is easy. Start saving on your insurance today.
Are you an existing customer?

Call (800) 300-8838